"Done When It's Fun?" Our Naive Timeline's Postmortem
“Done When It’s Fun?” Our Naive Timeline’s Postmortem
Our team started with a dream: to create a genre-bending RPG fueled by pure passion. We heard the siren song of “done when it’s fun,” a mantra that resonated with our indie spirit. We thought we were breaking free from corporate constraints, embracing artistic freedom. We were wrong.
The Allure of Infinite Possibility
Open the Wayline editors — pixel sprites, sheets, palettes, scenes — and export drop-in assets for Unity, Unreal, and Godot. Free to start, no signup.
The initial concept was intoxicating. A sprawling world, intricate crafting systems, branching narratives – everything felt within reach. “Done when it’s fun” meant chasing every interesting idea, every shiny new feature that popped into our heads. We imagined a game so compelling, players would lose themselves for hundreds of hours.
This quickly devolved into a chaotic mess. Scope creep became our constant companion. One week it was adding a fishing mini-game, the next it was redesigning the entire combat system. There was no clear definition of “done,” no measurable progress. It felt like we were building a castle on quicksand.
The Reality Bites
Six months in, we weren’t playable. We had assets, code fragments, and mountains of half-finished features. The joy had evaporated, replaced by a gnawing anxiety. Meetings became tense, filled with passive-aggressive comments and unspoken frustration.
Our original budget of $5,000, intended to cover freelance art and music, was bleeding dry. We’d sunk over 1,000 combined hours into the project, essentially working for free. We thought passion alone would suffice, but passion doesn’t pay the bills.
We reviewed our initial plan: a one-page document filled with high-level ideas and zero concrete deadlines. The only number we had was the budget. The reality of our situation was grim. Our naive, “fun-first” approach had backfired spectacularly.
Scope Creep: The Silent Killer
The fishing mini-game is a perfect example. It sounded fun, a nice diversion from the main quest. A developer spent two weeks implementing the core mechanics. An artist created custom fish models. A writer crafted witty dialogue for the fishmonger. The final result? It was buggy, shallow, and added nothing to the overall experience.
That fishing game was a microcosm of our entire project. We kept adding features that sounded good in isolation, without considering their impact on the overall scope or timeline. We lacked an MVP, a Minimum Viable Product, to define the core gameplay loop.
Motivation Dips and Communication Breakdowns
The lack of visible progress took its toll on motivation. When you’re constantly working on unfinished features, it’s hard to feel a sense of accomplishment. Small victories are crucial for maintaining team morale.
Our communication also suffered. Because there was no clear roadmap, nobody knew what they should be working on. Ambiguity bred confusion, leading to duplicated efforts and conflicting implementations. Simple questions turned into lengthy debates, eating up valuable development time.
A Lightweight Project Management Rescue
Recognizing our dire situation, we attempted to salvage the project. We abandoned the “done when it’s fun” mantra and embraced a more structured approach. We started by defining a clear MVP, focusing on the core gameplay loop.
We adopted iterative development, breaking down features into small, manageable tasks. Each task had a clear objective and a defined completion date. We used a simple Kanban board to track our progress and identify bottlenecks. This provided much-needed clarity and a sense of momentum.
User Testing and Feedback Loops
We organized playtesting sessions with friends and family. Their feedback was invaluable, highlighting glaring flaws in our design and identifying areas for improvement. We learned to prioritize user feedback over our own preconceived notions.
One playtester pointed out that our combat system was overly complex and punishing. We initially resisted this criticism, as we’d put a lot of effort into designing it. However, after observing other players struggle, we realized they were right. We simplified the combat mechanics, making the game more accessible and enjoyable.
The Unpleasant Truth: Time to Pivot
Despite our efforts, the damage was done. We had wasted too much time on irrelevant features and lacked the resources to bring our vision to fruition. After a long and difficult discussion, we decided to put the project on hold.
It was a painful decision, but ultimately the right one. We learned valuable lessons about the importance of planning, scope management, and team communication. We emerged from this experience wiser and more prepared for future projects.
Lessons Learned: Avoiding the “Fun First” Trap
So how can you avoid the pitfalls of the “done when it’s fun” approach? Here’s some hard-won advice:
Define a Clear MVP: What is the bare minimum required for your game to be fun and engaging? Focus on delivering that first.
Set Realistic Milestones: Break down your project into smaller, manageable tasks with defined deadlines. Use a project management tool to track your progress.
Prioritize Iterative Development: Work in short cycles, constantly testing and refining your game based on user feedback.
Establish Communication Protocols: Make sure everyone on your team knows what they should be working on and how to communicate effectively. Daily stand-up meetings can be helpful.
Embrace User Testing: Get your game in front of players early and often. Their feedback is invaluable for identifying flaws and improving the overall experience.
Kill Your Darlings: Be willing to cut features that aren’t working, even if you’re emotionally attached to them.
Track Time and Budget: Monitor your progress and make sure you’re staying within your budget. Don’t be afraid to ask for help if you’re struggling.
Document Everything: Keep clear documentation of design decisions, code, and assets. This will make it easier to onboard new team members and maintain the project.
“Done when it’s fun” can be a starting point, a spark of inspiration. But it can’t be your guiding principle. Passion is essential, but it must be tempered with planning, discipline, and a healthy dose of pragmatism. Otherwise, you’ll find yourself adrift in a sea of half-finished features, wondering where all the fun went.