Choosing Between Kanban and Scrum: Which Is Best for Indie Devs?

Kanban vs. Scrum: The Indie Dev’s Guide to Project Management

Project management. It sounds like a corporate buzzword, but for indie devs, it’s the difference between a finished game and a half-baked prototype gathering digital dust. The “dev journey” can be a winding, treacherous road. Let’s treat this like a UX review: how can we make the journey smoother?

We’ll explore how Kanban and Scrum can help, focusing on your unique needs and constraints as an indie. Forget rigid dogma; we’re talking practical adaptations.

Pain Points on the Indie Dev Journey

What are the common roadblocks that send indie projects spiraling?

Scope creep is a big one. A simple platformer suddenly needs a branching narrative and procedural generation.

Feature paralysis hits when you’re overwhelmed by possibilities, unable to prioritize and commit. Ideas are cheap; execution is everything.

Burnout looms when you’re working 80-hour weeks with no clear milestones in sight. Enthusiasm fades, and motivation plummets.

These aren’t abstract problems; they’re real threats to your game’s survival. A good project management system can act as a safety net, preventing these failures.

Kanban: The Visual Workflow

Kanban is a visual system. Imagine a whiteboard divided into columns: “To Do,” “In Progress,” “Testing,” and “Done.” You write tasks on sticky notes and move them across the board as you work.

The core principle is visualizing your workflow. This makes bottlenecks immediately obvious. Are all your tasks stuck in "Testing"? Maybe you need to focus on fixing bugs before adding new features.

Kanban is flexible. There are no fixed iterations or roles. You pull tasks as you have the capacity to work on them. This makes it ideal for projects with evolving requirements.

When it works: Kanban shines when you have a clear idea of what needs to be done, but the order isn’t critical. Maybe you’re working on art assets, sound design, or bug fixes.

The indie dev edge: Kanban adapts to your unpredictable schedule. If life throws a curveball, you can pause, adjust priorities, and jump back in without disrupting a rigid sprint cycle.

Scrum: The Iterative Approach

Scrum revolves around short cycles called sprints, typically lasting one to four weeks. At the beginning of each sprint, you select a set of tasks from your backlog to complete.

There are defined roles: the Product Owner (you, defining the vision), the Scrum Master (also likely you, facilitating the process), and the Development Team (again, probably you).

Daily stand-up meetings (brief check-ins) help track progress and identify roadblocks. At the end of each sprint, you review what you’ve accomplished and plan the next one.

When it works: Scrum excels when you need to deliver a working version of your game at regular intervals. It forces you to prioritize and focus on the most important features.

The indie dev edge: Those “arbitrary” deadlines within each sprint are useful. They force momentum, preventing projects from stalling due to perfectionism or feature creep. They can be surprisingly effective for combating procrastination.

Kanban vs. Scrum: A Step-by-Step Comparison

Let’s break it down with a focus on how this will affect you as a small team.

1. Setup:
   • Kanban: Create your columns and populate them with tasks. Simple and quick.
   • Scrum: Define your roles (even if you’re all of them), create a product backlog, and plan your first sprint. More upfront work.
2. Workflow:
   • Kanban: Pull tasks as you have capacity. Continuous flow.
   • Scrum: Work on the tasks selected for the current sprint. Time-boxed.
3. Adaptation:
   • Kanban: Easily adapt to changing priorities.
   • Scrum: Sprint goals are generally fixed. Changes are incorporated in the next sprint.
4. Meetings:
   • Kanban: Optional, ad-hoc meetings.
   • Scrum: Daily stand-ups, sprint planning, sprint review, sprint retrospective.
5. Overhead:
   • Kanban: Low overhead.
   • Scrum: Higher overhead due to ceremonies and defined roles.

Adapting to Reality: The Indie Hybrid

The best approach is often a hybrid.

Combine Kanban’s visual workflow and flexibility with Scrum’s iterative structure and focus on delivery.

Use sprints to plan larger milestones, but use Kanban within each sprint to manage individual tasks.

Ditch the unnecessary ceremonies. You don’t need a formal Scrum Master when you’re a solo dev.

Journaling: Your Secret Weapon

Regardless of which framework you choose, tracking your progress is crucial. This is where a game dev journal comes in.

A game dev journal is a place to record your daily progress, challenges, and insights. It’s a repository of knowledge that you can refer back to later.

Journaling techniques that boost problem-solving:

• Daily reflections: What did you accomplish today? What challenges did you face? What did you learn?
• Retrospectives: At the end of each week or sprint, review your progress and identify areas for improvement.
• Problem-solving logs: When you encounter a difficult bug or design challenge, document your troubleshooting process.
• Idea capture: Jot down new ideas as they come to you, even if they don’t fit into your current plan.

Many indie developers have testified about the benefits of using a game development log. They keep track of their progress, maintain consistency with devlogs, and organize their creative process.

Avoid the pitfall of vague entries. Be specific. Don’t just write “Fixed bug.” Write “Fixed bug in enemy AI that caused enemies to get stuck on corners. Implemented pathfinding adjustment to prevent recurrence.”

Journaling isn’t just about recording what you did; it’s about reflecting on why you did it and how you can improve. It’s about consciously tracking game development progress and turning lessons learned into future successes.

Want a better way to track your game development journey? Documenting your game dev process makes it easy to log your progress, organize your thoughts, and reflect on your work. Start your free trial today!