The Cost of Outsourcing Art vs. Learning to Draw

Posted by Gemma Ellison
./
August 2, 2025

The Cost of Outsourcing Art vs. Learning to Draw

Motivation in game development is a fickle beast. One day you’re energized to learn pixel art, the next you’re staring at freelance rates, wondering if outsourcing is the only way to meet your deadline. It’s a common struggle, particularly for indie developers. So, how do you choose?

Let’s break down the realities of outsourcing versus learning to draw, and arm you with a framework for making the right decision for your game and your sanity. We’ll follow the journey of one developer to illustrate the challenges and opportunities.

Case Study: Pixel Pushers and Tight Budgets

Imagine Sarah, a solo developer working on a retro-style RPG. Her budget is tight, around $5,000 total, and her timeline is even tighter – aiming for a release within a year. She needs character sprites, environment tiles, UI elements, and enemy designs. Sarah initially planned to outsource all the art.

Here’s where the reality check hits:

  • Outsourcing Costs: Getting quotes revealed that outsourcing all the art would consume at least $3,000, possibly more with revisions. That leaves a pittance for music, sound effects, marketing, and software.
  • Timeline Implications: Managing an artist (or multiple artists) adds significant communication overhead. Revisions can drag on, pushing back deadlines. Each iteration requires clear feedback, which takes time.
  • Artistic Control: Explaining the exact aesthetic Sarah envisioned proved difficult. Early drafts were often close, but not quite right, leading to frustrating back-and-forths.

Sarah realized she needed to re-evaluate. The initial appeal of saving time was being eroded by communication friction and budget constraints. She decided to explore learning pixel art herself, at least for some assets.

Actionable Steps: From Zero to Pixel Hero (Maybe)

Sarah took these steps to assess her options:

  1. Calculating the True Cost of Outsourcing: Beyond the initial quote, Sarah factored in revision costs (artists often charge extra for significant changes), communication time (email, meetings), and the risk of delays. She estimated adding 20% to each quote for revisions and calculated the hourly cost of her time spent managing the artist.
  2. Assessing Skill Gaps: Sarah identified her weaknesses: character animation and creating consistent tile sets. She decided to focus on learning those.
  3. Exploring Free Learning Resources: YouTube tutorials, free pixel art software like Piskel, and online communities like Pixelation became her go-to resources.
  4. Setting Realistic Learning Goals: Instead of trying to become a master artist in a month, Sarah focused on creating one passable character sprite. She broke down the task into smaller, manageable steps: learn basic anatomy, understand color palettes, practice animation loops.
  5. Prototyping and Iterating: Sarah created a simple prototype using her rudimentary art skills. This allowed her to test the gameplay and get feedback early, which helped refine her artistic direction.

Common Pitfalls (and How to Avoid Them)

Sarah stumbled upon several common pitfalls:

  • Underestimating Revision Needs: Sarah initially thought one or two revision rounds would be enough. She quickly realized that properly communicating her vision took more effort. Solution: Over-communicate upfront. Create detailed art briefs with references.
  • Unrealistic Practice Schedules: Attempting to cram hours of practice after a long day of coding led to burnout. Solution: Set aside 30-60 minutes each day for focused practice.
  • Perfectionism Paralysis: Getting bogged down in minor details prevented her from making progress. Solution: Embrace the “good enough” mentality, especially in the early stages. Remember, gameplay trumps graphics.
  • Ignoring the Time Cost: Even learning takes time, which impacts development timelines. Solution: Adjust your project timeline to accommodate learning.

A Framework for Your Decision

Here’s a framework to help you decide whether to outsource or learn to draw:

  1. Budget Analysis: How much can you realistically spend on art?
  2. Timeline Assessment: How much time do you have? Factor in learning time if you choose that route.
  3. Skill Inventory: What artistic skills do you already possess? What are the biggest gaps?
  4. Risk Tolerance: How comfortable are you with the potential risks of outsourcing (delays, communication issues)? How comfortable are you with the learning curve?
  5. Project Scope: What kind of art style does your game require? Can you achieve a simplified aesthetic that aligns with your current (or learnable) skills?

Sarah ultimately decided on a hybrid approach. She learned enough pixel art to create basic character sprites and environment tiles, saving a significant amount of money. She then outsourced the more complex character animations to a freelancer with a distinct, compatible style. This balanced her budget, timeline, and artistic vision.

Track Your Progress, One Brush Stroke at a Time

Learning to draw, or managing an artist, is a journey filled with ups and downs. Documenting your experiences – your successes, your frustrations, your artistic breakthroughs – can be incredibly valuable.

Consider using a game dev journal to track your progress. A game development log can help you:

  • Reflect on your artistic journey: What did you learn today? What challenges did you overcome? What could you have done better?
  • Refine your game development strategy: Are you spending too much time on art and neglecting other areas of development? Are your initial estimates accurate?
  • Stay consistent with devlogs: Use your journal entries as inspiration for your devlog posts, showcasing your progress to your audience.
  • Organize your creative process: Keep track of art briefs, sketches, and feedback.

Documenting your experiences and feelings while developing your game will increase self-awareness and inform future decisions. And if you are a solo developer, it can be extremely gratifying to look back on your work and see the progress.

Are you ready to take the next step in your game development journey? Start documenting your progress and refining your strategy with our journaling tool today! Track your progress, one brush stroke at a time